Buying Electronic Drums Vs. Acoustic Drums
This is always a tough call. Which type drum should you buy, the electric drums developed in the 80′s or the standard musician’s drum, the acoustic drum? Surprisingly, there may be some considerations that end this debate before it begins.
If budget is an issue, the acoustic drum set will cost less than its electric counterpart. If your budget is under $600, you are better off going with an acoustic drum over the low-end, headache-filled electric drum experience. In that $600 range, the aspiring drummer will only get a cheap electric drum set.
However, your practice area may affect your acoustic vs. electric drum decision as well. If you have a confined space or a space where the sound level needs to be controlled, electric drums are probably the better fit. Neighbors do not like acoustic drums.
The noise level of electric drums can be controlled by dialing down. Electric drums require far less space than acoustic drums so if you will be practicing in an apartment or flat, an electric drum set is probably the way to go.
Most drummers find it easier to start out on the standard acoustical drum. There is nothing that compares to the hands-on experience of the acoustical drum. Some musicians believe that to understand the electric drum, a drummer must start with acoustical drums.
Of course another consideration is your playing intent. It is hard to match the playing experience of acoustical drums but electric drums are better for recording. When practicing, the drummer can simply plug a CD player into the sound module. The accompanying drum sound will not overwhelm the music.
Another difference between these two drum sets is that electric drums do not require tuning and actual recording is easy. Simply plug to the mixing board and play away for great recordings.
Acoustic drums are pure. They offer more volume and a wider expressive sound range, especially when the hi-hat and cymbals are considered. While brushes are generally ineffective on electric drums, they are terrific with acoustic drums.
Most musicians feel that acoustic drums have more sex appeal than electric drums. If the drummer is performing on stage, electric drums can present a host of challenges. The drummer is often at the mercy of stage monitors. Electric drums are more difficult to assemble because there are numerous parts and wires. Yet, acoustic drums are larger and can be cumbersome to transport.
Once the beginning drummer has developed their skills, it is possible to merge the systems. Many professionals have found ways to use combinations of electric and acoustic drums.
